I Agree with Sam. Yes, AI Does Have a Communications Problem.


AI Has a Communications Problem

Sam Altman has been making the rounds, and in a recent interview with Bloomberg, he acknowledged that the AI industry has done a poor job communicating the benefits of the technology. It’s not often you hear “communications challenge” in a Bloomberg cover story, so of course I was instantly invested. Altman talked about the fear surrounding AI and the need to give people a greater sense that it will increase their agency rather than take it away. I agree with him, although I think AI companies also have to reckon with how much they contributed to the problem they now want to solve.

I spend a lot of time talking with professionals about AI. I teach it, lead sessions on it and listen to people talk about what excites them and what concerns them. I’ve seen the mood shift. Many people understand what AI can do and are excited about what it may eventually make possible. How we get there is where the uncertainty begins. People have questions about human agency, job security, the environmental costs of all this computing, the use of creative work and who gets to make the rules.

The biggest source of resistance I hear is remarkably consistent: people feel like they’re training their replacements. That is a difficult mindset to overcome with another workshop on prompting.

Early in the generative AI boom, Altman described AI as an “extension of human will.” I still like that description because it puts people at the center. I bring my judgment, experience and ideas, and AI gives me greater capacity to do something with them. But I’m not sure that’s the story people are hearing anymore. They’re hearing predictions that AI could eliminate entire categories of jobs, perform much of today’s knowledge work and eventually surpass human intelligence. They’re also hearing that companies may need fewer employees because the people who remain will be able to produce so much more.

Then I saw this post from Mike Drucker.

I laughed because it captures the communications problem better than I probably can. Use AI because it’s the future. Prepare for it to take your job. Expect it to solve enormous problems. Worry that it could destroy us. And whatever you do, don’t fall behind. That’s a lot to ask people to hold at once.

When someone in one of my sessions tells me she feels like she’s training her replacement, I think we need to pay attention to what she’s been hearing, including what she may be hearing from her own company. Many organizations are introducing AI through the language of efficiency and productivity. Do more. Move faster. Save time. Reduce costs. Those are reasonable business goals, but put them next to years of predictions about AI replacing knowledge work and employees can connect the dots themselves. If AI allows 8 people to do the work of 10, they’re going to wonder what happens to the other 2.

This is where the communications problem gets much bigger than messaging. If AI saves me 5 hours a week, what happens to those 5 hours? Do I get more time for work that requires my experience and judgment? Does the company simply expect more? Does my team get smaller? I hear versions of these questions all the time. Companies want employees to experiment with AI, learn it and find new ways to use it. If they also want employees to believe AI will increase their agency, they need to explain what happens to the productivity gains those employees are being asked to create.

The Audience Changes the Message

There’s another problem here that communications people will recognize immediately: audience. AI leaders often make sweeping statements about the future without considering how differently those statements will be received. An investor may hear growth. A CEO may hear productivity. An employee may hear fewer jobs. A parent may wonder what kind of career her child should prepare for. And a community being asked to approve another data center may be thinking about something else entirely.

The data center issue is a good example. AI requires extraordinary amounts of computing infrastructure, which means more facilities, electricity and, in many cases, water. There are legitimate debates about the scale of those impacts and how they compare with other industries. But if a data center is coming to your community, the comparison you probably care about isn’t how much water an almond uses. You want to know what the facility will mean for your water supply, electricity rates and community. I think those are fair questions, and I think the industry sometimes gets so focused on defending AI that it misses what people are actually asking.

People can believe AI is worth building and still want to understand what building it will require. They can be excited about the technology and want rules around how it is developed. They can use AI every day and still worry about what it will mean for their profession. These concerns are reasonable, especially as AI begins affecting more consequential parts of people’s lives.

Maybe We Need a Minute

This is why I’m increasingly interested in some of the slowdowns being discussed around AI development and infrastructure. We’ve spent the past few years talking about AI as though faster is always better. Faster models, faster adoption, faster infrastructure and faster progress toward AGI. But I wonder whether a little breathing room might actually be useful.

Leaders are still figuring out what responsible adoption looks like. Regulators are trying to catch up. Employees are trying to understand what AI means for their careers. Communities are being asked to make decisions about infrastructure that could affect them for decades. Giving people and institutions time to understand what is happening, establish rules and make deliberate choices may ultimately make adoption easier. Technical progress and public readiness don’t always move at the same speed, and I think the industry would benefit from taking that seriously.

If AI Needs a Rebrand

Which brings me back to Altman’s communications problem. If the AI industry wants to improve its reputation, it needs to reconsider both the story it is telling and some of the decisions underneath that story. A new tagline isn’t going to accomplish much if people’s experiences continue to contradict the promises.

I would start with credible rules and accountability. The companies building the most powerful AI systems shouldn’t be the only ones deciding what responsible development looks like. Governments and independent oversight bodies have a role, and the industry should be helping establish standards that people can trust. International cooperation matters too, even if creating consistent regulation across countries will take time.

I’d also like to see AI leaders become more careful with their predictions. Tell us what AI can do today, what researchers believe may happen and what remains uncertain. There is a meaningful difference between discussing possible job displacement and declaring that entire professions are headed for extinction. When the person making the prediction also runs the company building the technology, the distinction matters.

The industry also needs to get better at discussing tradeoffs without trying to win every argument. If a community is worried about a data center, answer the questions that community is asking. If creators are concerned about how their work is being used, address those concerns directly. If workers are worried about their jobs, promising that AI will eventually create new kinds of employment isn’t much of an answer to someone wondering whether she’ll have a job next year.

And I would put human agency back at the center of the conversation.

I keep coming back to how most of us experienced generative AI in the beginning. We were asking ChatGPT to rewrite an email, summarize a document, plan a trip or explain something we didn’t understand. It was useful, sometimes surprisingly so, and you could immediately see what the technology allowed you to do.

That’s still the AI story I find most interesting. What can someone do with this technology that she couldn’t do before? What can she learn? What becomes easier? Where can she spend more time on work that requires judgment, creativity and experience? Those are the conversations where I still see people get excited about AI.

But increasingly, there’s another question sitting underneath that excitement: What happens to me?

AI companies can improve how they communicate about that question, and employers can too. Eventually, though, the answer has to come from the choices they make. If companies want people to believe AI will increase human agency, people need to see evidence of that in their jobs, their communities and their lives.

That would be a pretty good place for the AI rebrand to start.

Comms FutureLAB

Comms FutureLab is a media platform for communications and marketing leaders who are endlessly curious about the future of our profession. Through thoughtful analysis of AI, media, leadership, trust and organizational change, we help today's leaders prepare for tomorrow's challenges and opportunities.

Read more from Comms FutureLAB
AI Workflow Automation: Examples, Tools, Best Practices

We're Changing How We Use AI. Are We Changing How We Manage It? AI is becoming more involved in how we work. A recent announcement from OpenAI raises questions about what happens when the technology we've come to depend on changes. If you've spent hours building a custom GPT, you might want to pay attention to December 11, 2026. That's the date OpenAI plans to retire custom GPTs and move users toward plugins. For anyone who has invested time creating a specialized AI assistant, this is a...

When Every Meeting Is Recorded, What Happens to Candor

When Every Meeting Is Recorded, What Happens to Candor? AI meeting assistants are becoming part of everyday work. New research raises questions about what happens when those tools start evaluating the people in the room. I recently attended a meeting with almost as many AI agents as human participants. 😅 Between meeting assistants, recording devices and smart glasses, I’m starting to wonder how much of our working lives are being documented, analyzed and stored somewhere. A few weeks ago, I...

Your Embargo Needs an Internal Comms Plan I’m working on a project with an organization that has a longstanding practice: employees hear company news 24 hours before it’s announced publicly. I understand the reasoning. Employees shouldn’t routinely learn important news about their company from a news alert, LinkedIn post or reporter. But 24 hours can be a long time when you’re also working with media under embargo. An embargo gives reporters access to information before an announcement with...